This article was originally written for Liberal Conspiracy.
Every few months, newspapers decide to have a pop at Oxford and Cambridge for institutionally discriminating against a particular section of society that isn’t white, male and public school educated.
This time it’s the turn of the Guardian to criticise Oxford University, presenting statistics obtained under a freedom on information request that reveal that white applicants are up to twice as likely to get a place as applicants from ethnic minority backgrounds. No article attacking one of these ancient institutions would be truly balanced without attacking the other, of course, so Cambridge comes under fire for older statistics suggesting a similar pattern.
Having been to Cambridge, I can say anecdotally that ethnic minority students certainly were underrepresented there. My brown face – despite the ludicrously long hair sitting on top of it at the time – was duly splashed on the front cover of the college prospectus presumably to present a facade of a diversity that didn’t really exist.
But the statistics presented by the Guardian are misleading in that while they suggest correlation, they fall far short of proving the kind of causation asserted by the article.
Oxbridge is being unfairly criticised for discriminating against minority students in the same way it is often unfairly criticised for discriminating against working class students.
The real problem lies much further down the line, with the schooling system and with wider society.
Every now and again stories will emerge about a straight-A student complaining that Oxford or Cambridge didn’t offer them a place. The trouble is, almost everyone applying to Oxbridge is a straight-A student, so much of the final selection comes down to performance at an often gruelling interview.
Public school students tend to be prepped far in advance for these interviews. They know what to expect, what to read around, how to act and most importantly how to project a confidence that will come across well in an educational environment based on supervisions and tutorials which favour the bold.
Students at many state schools, particularly ones in deprived areas that are less likely to attract teachers who were educated at Oxbridge themselves and know the system, cannot provide the same level of silver spoon-fed service. I was lucky in that the head of Sixth Form at my state comprehensive had been to Cambridge and could give me a punishingly realistic mock interview, as could my Oxford educated father. I suspect that’s not the norm.
It’s a sad fact that public schools are predominantly the preserve of the middle classes. It’s also a sad fact that ethnic minority students are more likely to be from poorer backgrounds with parents less able to pay for them to attend public schools.
State school attendance at Oxbridge remains poor. Last year, state school attendance at Cambridge hit a 30-year high at 63.3%. But considering only 12% of all students attend public schools, it shows that those who have been privately educated remain disproportionately represented there.
The statistics are a sad reflection not on Oxbridge, but on wider society. Oxford and Cambridge can do all they like to encourage more students from ethnic minority, working class and state school backgrounds to apply, but unless inequalities much lower down the chain in the education system and in society are tackled, the problem is not going to go away.
3 thoughts on “Oxbridge is being unfairly attacked for institutional bias against ethnic minorities”
I largely agree – for the last two years I’ve done lots of mock interviews for a charity and it is obvious the huge benefit that some schools are able to provide.
Is the full data available? Would be interesting to see if ethnic minority students from a particular background are more/less likely to get in than those from similar background. Ie if we have lots minority kids from ‘poor’ state schools applying for Medicine and Law it isn’t surprising if the numbers are underrepresented. If we have ethnic minority kids from the top public schools applying for Classics and Anglo Saxon, Norse and Celtic.
Sorry to finish off If we have ethnic minority kids from the top public schools applying for Classics and Anglo Saxon, Norse and Celtic then race may well be more of an issue
I read a lot of interesting articles here. Probably you spend a
lot of time writing, i know how to save you a lot of time, there is an online tool that creates
readable, google friendly articles in seconds, just type in google – laranitas
free content source